Stadnyk v. Nedoshytko, 2017 IL App (1st) 152103-U views the counterclaim-versus-affirmative defense distinction through the prism of a statutory partition suit involving co-owners of a Chicago apartment building. The plaintiff sued to declare the parties’ respective ownership rights in the subject property. After the court issued a partition order finding the plaintiff and defendants had …
Tag Archives: apportionment
Constructive Fraud in IL Mechanics’ Lien Suits: A Case Study
Here’s one from the vault. While dated, the case is still relevant for its cogent discussion of important and recurring mechanics’ lien litigation issues. In Springfield Heating and Air Conditioning, Inc. v. 3947-55 King Drive at Oakwood, LLC, 387 Ill App 3d 906 (1st Dist. 2009), the First District examined the concept of constructive fraud …
Continue reading “Constructive Fraud in IL Mechanics’ Lien Suits: A Case Study”