Illegality Defense Doesn’t Defeat HVAC Subcontractor’s Damage Claim Versus General Contractor on Chicago Transit Authority Project (N.D. 2015)

I’ve written before on the illegality defense to breach of contract suits.  It’s bedrock contract law that an agreement to do something criminal (example – murder, arson, selling drugs, etc.) is unenforceable against the person who doesn’t perform (example: if I fail to pay a hit man, he can’t sue me for the $).  The illegality defense also applies in the civil …

Contractual Illegality and Medical Fee-Sharing

A contract law axiom states that an illegal contract is unenforceable.  The prototypical example involves a plaintiff attempting to sue on a contract that violates a statute or encourages criminal or fraudulent conduct.  Those situations clearly give rise to an illegality defense.  But what if a contract term technically violates a statute, but the resulting damage is either trivial or nonexistent? A …