Requests to Admit in Illinois: How and When To Respond (The 28-Day Rule)


I once read a tongue-in-cheek article that said if you’re ever served with a Request to Admit Fact (RTA), you should staple it to your forehead. (Ouch!)

That way, you won’t forget about the RTA and miss the 28-day deadline to send your sworn responses to the opposing side.  And while some recent cases may have softened Illinois’ draconian RTA rules, the hyperbolic sentiment expressed in the “staple statement” endures: a failure to timely respond to an RTA can have grave consequences for your case.  The main one being that the facts (or documents) contained in the RTA can be deemed admitted against you.

Once that happens, the party sending the RTA can move for summary judgment and win all or most of his case.

Armagan v. Pesha, 2014 IL App (1st) 121840 examines the question of when the 28-day timing requirement starts and ends and when the service of and response to an RTA is deemed complete under Illinois law.

The plaintiff deposited over 250 gold coins with the defendants who operated a rare coin shop.  Plaintiff alleged he placed the coins with the defendants temporarily with the understanding that plaintiff could always get them back.  Several months later when plaintiff asked for the coins back, defendants apparently refused and plaintiff sued for conversion, breach of bailment and other claims.

During discovery, plaintiff mailed an RTA on defendants on November 18, 2010.  Defendants filed their response with the court on December 17, 2010 (29 days later) and mailed the response to plaintiff that same day.  Plaintiff then moved to deem the RTA facts admitted on the basis that defendant missed the 28-day deadline by one day.

The trial court agreed (November 18 service is complete November 22, 2010; December 17, 2010 service is complete on December 21, 2010 – 29 days after November 22, 2010), deemed the facts admitted and entered summary judgment for plaintiff for almost $500,000.  An expensive, one-day mistake to be sure.  Defendants appealed.

Held: Trial Court reversed.  Defendants’ RTA response was timely under Illinois Supreme Court Rule 12.

The First District found that defendants timely responded to the RTA.  In doing so, the Court discussed the interplay between Supreme Court Rules 216, 12 and 11 which govern RTAs and the manner of serving documents. The key rules:

the purpose of Rule 216  is to narrow issues for trial and only requires the responding party to serve his responses within the 28-day deadline; as opposed to filing them with the court within 28 days;

– Rule 216 requires only that the RTA responses be served (by the responding party), not received (by the requesting party) within 28 days;

– failing to comply with Rule 216’s requirements can result in a judicial admission of the facts contained in the RTA;

– Under Rule 12(c), service is complete four (4) days after mailing;

– the method of service differs from proof of service;

– serving a document by U.S. mail is an acceptable method of service; 

– Rule 11 specifically allows a party to serve documents (other than complaint) by U.S. mail (“regular” mail);

¶¶ 16-20.

Application: Plaintiff mailed his RTA on November 18, 2010.  Under Rule 12, service of the RTA was complete on November 22, 2010 – four days later.  Defendants then had 28 days – through December 20, 2010 – to serve their response.  Since defendants served their RTA response by placing it in the mail on December 17, 2010, they complied with the 28-day deadline (with three days to spare). ¶ 23.

Policy concerns also motivated the Court’s reversal.  It noted that Illinois has a broad policy of cases being resolved on the merits instead of technicalities and that discovery is not designed for tactical gamesmanship or a trap for the unwary.  Accordingly, the Court would have allowed the defendants response even if it was late under Rule 183 (which governs extension of time for “good cause”).  ¶¶ 25-26.

Take-aways: A Request to Admit is the quintessential “gotcha” discovery device.  The serving party hopes you will blow the 28-day deadline and then do exactly what the plaintiff did here: try to get the facts deemed admitted against you.

This case seems to strike a fair balance between giving teeth to a discovery tool while at the same time being willing to look at the realities of litigation practice, where the exigencies of the moment practically dictate last-minute responses.

In hindsight, the defendants’ attorney probably should have hand-delivered and faxed (and e-mailed) his response instead of mailing it.  That would have saved him a lot of time and (I imagine) frantic energy trying to undo the $500,000 judgment against his client.

 

Published by

PaulP

Litigation attorney at Bielski Chapman, Ltd. representing businesses and individuals in business litigation, post-judgment enforcement, collections and real estate litigation.

597 thoughts on “Requests to Admit in Illinois: How and When To Respond (The 28-Day Rule)”

  1. Pingback: viagra online
  2. Pingback: viagra experiences
  3. Pingback: cialis coupon 2016
  4. Pingback: buy cialis rush
  5. Pingback: celecoxib brand
  6. Pingback: wiki keflex
  7. Pingback: cymbalta prices
  8. Pingback: cialis 20 mg cost
  9. Pingback: cialis in europe
  10. Pingback: viagra costs
  11. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg
  12. Pingback: viagra for sale
  13. Pingback: viagra sex
  14. Pingback: nizagara vs viagra
  15. Pingback: viagra meaning
  16. Pingback: cialis tadalafil
  17. Pingback: viagra roman
  18. Pingback: cost of viagra
  19. Pingback: jodi west viagra
  20. Pingback: cialis wikipedia
  21. Pingback: cialis daily use
  22. Pingback: sex on viagra
  23. Pingback: viagra imposter
  24. Pingback: acheter viagra 25
  25. Pingback: cialis otc months
  26. Pingback: viagra on sale
  27. Pingback: buy cialis
  28. Pingback: viagra logo
  29. Pingback: goodrx cialis
  30. Pingback: free viagra
  31. Pingback: mexican viagra
  32. Pingback: cialis 10 mg
  33. Pingback: womens viagra
  34. Pingback: gabapentin 300 mg
  35. Pingback: vardenafil price
  36. Pingback: sildenafil cost uk
  37. Pingback: meloxicam for cats
  38. Pingback: what is metoprolol
  39. Pingback: viagra soft gel
  40. Pingback: cvs cialis cost
  41. Pingback: levitra wiki
  42. Pingback: prednisone 20mg
  43. Pingback: buspar medicine
  44. Pingback: zanaflex 4mg
  45. Pingback: wellbutrin anxiety
  46. Pingback: voltaren reviews
  47. Pingback: clonidine dosage
  48. Pingback: flagyl antibiotic
  49. Pingback: snorting viagra
  50. Pingback: cialis ingredients
  51. Pingback: sildenafil capsule
  52. Pingback: 500 mg amoxicillin
  53. Pingback: amoxicillin dose
  54. Pingback: cephalexin 250 mg
  55. Pingback: cleocin
  56. Pingback: azithromycin 250mg
  57. Pingback: cialis overdose
  58. Pingback: cialis mastercard
  59. Pingback: buy levitra online
  60. Pingback: cialis online
  61. Pingback: cialis 10 mg price
  62. Pingback: canadian viagra
  63. Pingback: no rx viagra
  64. Pingback: vardenafil cost
  65. Pingback: what is furosemide
  66. Pingback: careprost china
  67. Pingback: clomid fsh
  68. Pingback: domperidone mg
  69. Pingback: cialis soft pills
  70. Pingback: cialis 20mg
  71. Pingback: tadalafil online
  72. Pingback: best viagra prices
  73. Pingback: homemade viagra
  74. Pingback: viagra connect cvs
  75. Pingback: omeprazole baby
  76. Pingback: celexa vs cymbalta
  77. Pingback: herbal viagra
  78. Pingback: atorvastatin 40
  79. Pingback: generic viagra
  80. Pingback: sildenafil 50 mg
  81. Pingback: viagrakari.com
  82. Pingback: viagra otc
  83. Pingback: 1
  84. Pingback: cialis best price
  85. Pingback: cialis from canada
  86. Pingback: low cost cialis
  87. Pingback: viagra uten resept
  88. Pingback: viagra wirkung
  89. Pingback: tadalafil citrate
  90. Pingback: 360 viagra
  91. Pingback: meritking
  92. Pingback: elexusbet
  93. Pingback: eurocasino
  94. Pingback: madridbet
  95. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  96. Pingback: eurocasino
  97. Pingback: eurocasino
  98. Pingback: meritking
  99. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  100. Pingback: cialis 10mg dosage
  101. Pingback: zithromax tablets
  102. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  103. Pingback: viagra 25mg cost
  104. Pingback: viagra canada
  105. Pingback: madridbet
  106. Pingback: trcasino
  107. Pingback: elexusbet
  108. Pingback: trcasino
  109. Pingback: tombala siteleri
  110. Pingback: tombala siteleri
  111. Pingback: tombala siteleri
  112. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  113. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  114. Pingback: augmentin espanol
  115. Pingback: bactrim ivpb
  116. Pingback: cephalexin label
  117. Pingback: clindamycin dosage
  118. Pingback: zithromax dosing
  119. Pingback: flagyl iv
  120. Pingback: azithromycin benzo
  121. Pingback: keflex generic
  122. Pingback: child porn
  123. Pingback: meritroyalbet
  124. Pingback: eurocasino
  125. Pingback: mazhor4sezon
  126. Pingback: filmfilmfilmes
  127. Pingback: gRh9UPV
  128. Pingback: 9-05-2022
  129. Pingback: kinoteatrzarya.ru
  130. Pingback: TopGun2022
  131. Pingback: Xvideos
  132. Pingback: XVIDEOSCOM Videos
  133. Pingback: ivanesva
  134. Pingback: Netflix
  135. Pingback: FILM
  136. Pingback: designchita.ru
  137. Pingback: YA-krasneyu
  138. Pingback: design-human.ru
  139. Pingback: designmsu.ru
  140. Pingback: vkl-design.ru
  141. Pingback: irida-design.ru
  142. Pingback: psy-
  143. Pingback: projectio
  144. Pingback: psy online
  145. Pingback: Gz92uNNH
  146. Pingback: do-posle-psihologa
  147. Pingback: uels ukrain
  148. Pingback: bahis siteleri
  149. Pingback: DPTPtNqS
  150. Pingback: qQ8KZZE6
  151. Pingback: D6tuzANh
  152. Pingback: SHKALA TONOV
  153. Pingback: chelovek-iz-90-h
  154. Pingback: 3Hk12Bl
  155. Pingback: 3NOZC44
  156. Pingback: 01211
  157. Pingback: tor-lyubov-i-grom
  158. Pingback: film-tor-2022
  159. Pingback: hd-tor-2022
  160. Pingback: hdorg2.ru
  161. Pingback: JXNhGmmt
  162. Pingback: Psikholog
  163. Pingback: netstate.ru
  164. Pingback: 3forming
  165. Pingback: 3gateway
  166. Pingback: Link
  167. Pingback: psy
  168. Pingback: bit.ly
  169. Pingback: cleantalkorg2.ru
  170. Pingback: bucha killings
  171. Pingback: War in Ukraine
  172. Pingback: Ukraine
  173. Pingback: viagra
  174. Pingback: site
  175. Pingback: sildenafil citrate
  176. Pingback: stats
  177. Pingback: revatio
  178. Pingback: Ukraine-war
  179. Pingback: movies
  180. Pingback: gidonline
  181. Pingback: viagra generic
  182. Pingback: web
  183. Pingback: film.8filmov.ru
  184. Pingback: video
  185. Pingback: filmgoda.ru
  186. Pingback: rodnoe-kino-ru
  187. Pingback: confeitofilm
  188. Pingback: stat.netstate.ru
  189. Pingback: sY5am
  190. Pingback: Dom drakona
  191. Pingback: JGXldbkj
  192. Pingback: aOuSjapt
  193. Pingback: ìûøëåíèå
  194. Pingback: psikholog moskva
  195. Pingback: pornoizle}
  196. Pingback: A片
  197. Pingback: Dim Drakona 2022
  198. Pingback: TwnE4zl6
  199. Pingback: psy 3CtwvjS
  200. Pingback: lalochesia
  201. Pingback: film onlinee
  202. Pingback: 3qAIwwN
  203. Pingback: video-2
  204. Pingback: sezons.store
  205. Pingback: psy-news.ru
  206. Pingback: 000-1
  207. Pingback: 3SoTS32
  208. Pingback: 3DGofO7
  209. Pingback: rftrip.ru
  210. Pingback: madridbet
  211. Pingback: dolpsy.ru
  212. Pingback: kin0shki.ru
  213. Pingback: 3o9cpydyue4s8.ru
  214. Pingback: mb588.ru
  215. Pingback: newsukraine.ru
  216. Pingback: tftl.ru
  217. Pingback: brutv
  218. Pingback: site 2023
  219. Pingback: grandpashabet
  220. Pingback: 1c789.ru
  221. Pingback: cttdu.ru
  222. Pingback: 1703
  223. Pingback: hdserial2023.ru
  224. Pingback: serialhd2023.ru
  225. Pingback: matchonline2022.ru
  226. Pingback: bit.ly/3OEzOZR
  227. Pingback: bit.ly/3gGFqGq
  228. Pingback: Grandpashabet
  229. Pingback: bep5w0Df
  230. Pingback: icf
  231. Pingback: 24hours-news
  232. Pingback: uluro-ado
  233. Pingback: irannews.ru
  234. Pingback: klondayk2022
  235. Pingback: madridbet
  236. Pingback: 2022-film
  237. Pingback: Meritking
  238. Pingback: kahve oyun
  239. Pingback: fuck google
  240. Pingback: okey oyna
  241. Pingback: madridbet
  242. Pingback: https://gdznew.ru/
  243. Pingback: 2023
  244. Pingback: porn
  245. Pingback: meritking
  246. Pingback: fuck google
  247. Pingback: video.vipspark.ru
  248. Pingback: vitaliy-abdulov.ru
  249. Pingback: psychophysics.ru
  250. Pingback: meritking
  251. Pingback: grandpashabet
  252. Pingback: child porn
  253. Pingback: canlı sex hattı
  254. Pingback: meritking
  255. Pingback: porn
  256. Pingback: meritking
  257. Pingback: grandpashabet
  258. Pingback: glee
  259. Pingback: xxx
  260. Pingback: ghaziabad escorts
  261. Pingback: meritking
  262. Pingback: meritking giriş
  263. Pingback: xxx
  264. Pingback: mount abu escorts
  265. Pingback: grandpashabet
  266. Pingback: izmir escort
  267. Pingback: tekirdağ
  268. Pingback: porn
  269. Pingback: child porn
  270. Pingback: fuck google
  271. Pingback: fuck
  272. Pingback: xxlargeseodigi
  273. Pingback: porn
  274. Pingback: porn
  275. Pingback: bağcılar escort
  276. Pingback: porn
  277. Pingback: ooohd3.ru
  278. Pingback: sitemap
  279. Pingback: child porn
  280. Pingback: cleantalkorg3.ru
  281. Pingback: fbofficial.ru
  282. Pingback: LORD FILM
  283. Pingback: sikiş
  284. Pingback: kin
  285. Pingback: kinnit
  286. Pingback: jz
  287. Pingback: nlp
  288. Pingback: time
  289. Pingback: sex
  290. Pingback: rasshifrovka karti
  291. Pingback: konsultaciya
  292. Pingback: more
  293. Pingback: porn
  294. Pingback: 9999
  295. Pingback: porn
  296. Pingback: 7
  297. Pingback: porn
  298. Pingback: batmanapollo.ru
  299. Pingback: child porn
  300. Pingback: 777
  301. Pingback: wlw.su
  302. Pingback: vxi.su
  303. Pingback: nlpvip.ru
  304. Pingback: porn
  305. Pingback: çeşme transfer
  306. Pingback: porn
  307. Pingback: porn
  308. Pingback: manipulyation
  309. Pingback: child porn
  310. Pingback: psykholog
  311. Pingback: child porn
  312. Pingback: izmir travesti
  313. Pingback: porn
  314. Pingback: nevşehir escort
  315. Pingback: kıbrıs escort
  316. Pingback: 354
  317. Pingback: esenyurt escort
  318. Pingback: kiino4k.ru
  319. Pingback: hd porno izle
  320. Pingback: child porn
  321. Pingback: new 2024
  322. Pingback: datça escort
  323. Pingback: izmir travesti
  324. Pingback: batman apollo
  325. Pingback: film2024
  326. Pingback: 123 Movies
  327. Pingback: yasam ayavefe
  328. Pingback: child porn
  329. Pingback: 000
  330. Pingback: kralbet
  331. Pingback: samorazvitiepsi
  332. Pingback: 911
  333. Pingback: list
  334. Pingback: a
  335. Pingback: child porn
  336. Pingback: porn
  337. Pingback: child porn
  338. Pingback: grandpashabet
  339. Pingback: grandpashabet
  340. Pingback: grandpashabet
  341. Pingback: child porn
  342. Pingback: grandpashabet
  343. Pingback: child porn
  344. Pingback: casino porn
  345. Pingback: grandpashabet
  346. Pingback: cratosroyalbet
  347. Pingback: porn
  348. Pingback: child porn
  349. Pingback: child porn
  350. Pingback: travesti.site
  351. Pingback: child porn
  352. Pingback: porn
  353. Pingback: child porn
  354. Pingback: animal porn
  355. Pingback: animal porn
  356. Pingback: animal porn
  357. Pingback: animal porn
  358. Pingback: human design
  359. Pingback: vassycalvados.fr
  360. Pingback: lugabet giriş
  361. Pingback: betgross giriş
  362. Pingback: grandpashabet
  363. Pingback: child porn
  364. Pingback: child porn
  365. Pingback: jojobet
  366. Pingback: jojobet twitter

Comments are closed.